Humanize From Discovery Institute's Center on Human Exceptionalism
Topic

Julian Savulescu

team-of-doctors-having-discussion-in-hospital-corridor-187022751-stockpack-adobestock
Team of doctors having discussion in hospital corridor

When Bioethicists Attack Medical Conscience

Many big shots in the bioethics community continue to argue against “medical conscience,” insisting that doctors should be forced to perform all requested legal medical procedures — even if it involves the taking of human life — that can produce the result the patient wants.

In the latest ani-conscience broadside, published in the professional journal Bioethics, two internationally known bioethicists, Julian Savulescu and Udo Schuklenk, take an almost absolutist position:

Our argument is that patients have a right to receive health care when four necessary conditions are satisfied (citations omitted):

  1. The treatment is legal in that jurisdiction.
  2. Providing the treatment is consistent with constraints of distributive justice.
  3. The treatment is in the patient’s interests.
  4. The patient autonomously desires the treatment.

The doctors define “patient’s interest” as a “benefit recognisable within accepted professional standards of benefit and harm.” Note carefully that these are often ideological, as opposed to medical, positions.

Read More ›
depression-grief-or-fail-with-a-mature-doctor-in-a-hospital-663223192-stockpack-adobestock
Depression, grief or fail with a mature doctor in a hospital looking unhappy for healthcare or medical. Stress, mistake or loss with a sad man medicine professional in a professional medicare clinic
Image Credit: N Felix/peopleimages.com - Adobe Stock

Attacks on Medical Conscience Would Force Doctors to Take Human Life

Legalizing euthanasia/assisted suicide, abortion, and transgender interventions for dysphoric children is only the beginning of the ongoing destruction of Hippocratic moral values in medicine. Once such interventions are legal, activists next insist that they become readily available. But many (and I hope most) doctors want nothing to do with causing death or interfering with the normal functioning of healthy bodies. Indeed, many assisted suicide, abortion, and gender ideologues complain that too few doctors willingly participate in these procedures, as is sometimes protected by the law. These “medical conscience” rights inhibit the increasing hegemony of utilitarian medical values in health care. As a result, once life-taking or mutilating procedures become legal, efforts soon begin to conscript unwilling medical professionals into performing Read More ›